Skip to Main content
  • Butcher & Barrel

Currently not accepting online orders
Grilled lamb chops with herb crust and vibrant sides

Menu

416 East 4th Street, Huntingburg, IN
Dinner
Drinks

Dinner

Appetizers

  • Smoked Cream Cheese

    pecan smoke infused and seasoned cream cheese - jalapeno melange, crostini
    $12.00
  • BBQ-terie

    pecan smoked brisket, sticky chicky, Hoosier hot link, with house pickles, one slice of candy bacon, BBQ sauce, and cornbread
    $26.00
  • Jumbo Crab Cake

    lump and claw crab meat in 3 cakes with a creole remoulade
    $23.00
  • Shrimp Cocktail

    4 tiger shrimp with horseradish cocktail sauce
    $15.00
  • Butcher Bacon

    savory thick-cut bacon with our sweet heat rub and bourbon maple dipping sauce, three - 10, five - 15
    $10.00+
  • Black & Bleu Flat Iron Sizzler

    Fire‑grilled flat iron steak topped with chunky bleu cheese, served sizzling hot in a cast‑iron skillet alongside warm, house‑made naan.
    $25.00
  • Bread Basket

    fresh baked assortment of focaccia, cornbread, and sourdough, served with whipped butter, olive oil, and balsamic
    $7.00
  • Panko-Crusted Deviled Egg

    A crisp panko‑coated egg white filled with a devilishly creamy, umami‑rich yolk blend for a playful twist on a classic bite.
    $25.00
  • Bavarian Pretzel

    A giant Tell City Bavarian pretzel served warm with our house‑made beer cheese and the famous Kelly’s mustard — the perfect shareable starter.
    $14.00

Soups

  • Lobster Bisque

    A velvety, slow‑simmered bisque enriched with sweet Atlantic lobster, aromatic herbs, and a touch of cream for a luxuriously smooth finish
    $12.00
  • Chef's Choice Soup

    a weekly rotating house-made soup featuring a thoughtfully crafted combination of fresh ingredients selected by our chef. cup $9, bowl $12
    $9.00

Salads

  • Black & Bleu Strawberry Salad

    Fresh romaine hearts adorned with sirloin steak, strawberries, chunky bleu cheese, toasted walnuts, croutons, and our strawberry Dijon vinaigrette.
    $23.00
  • Asian Wedge Salad

    Crisp romaine tossed with a bright soy‑ginger vinaigrette, sweet mandarin oranges, and crunchy toasted ramen for the perfect balance of freshness and texture
    $11.00
  • Caesar

    fresh romaine hearts with parmigiana reggiano, house dressing and croutons
    $11.00
  • House Salad

    spring mix with red onion, cherry tomato, cucumber, and choice of dressing
    $10.00

Center of the Plate

all steaks are aged a minimum of 21 days and are hand cut by our in house butcher
  • French Cut Double Bone Pork Chop

    14 oz, chargrilled and juicy French cut double bone chop, plus one side
    $32.00
  • Hand Cut Filet

    8 oz, premium beef filet, aged and tender with our house demi glaze, plus one side
    $55.00
  • Lionsmane Mushroom Steak

    A marinated lionshead mushroom, fire‑grilled for a smoky char, served over silky sweet potato purée with rich, creamy spinach.
    $32.00
  • Ribeye

    18 oz, prime beef, thick cut, well-marbled and chargrilled to perfection, plus one side
    $59.00
  • New York Strip

    16 oz, full-bodied cut, slightly firmer than ribeye, plus one side
    $47.00
  • The Huntingburger

    steak grind charbroiled, topped with sautéed onions, with a side of beer cheese, and bacon jam on a brioche bun, plus one side
    $24.00

Entrees

  • Hamilton Feast

    brisket, pulled pork, & sticky chicky served with one side, and cornbread
    $29.00
  • Chicken Piccata

    Airline-cut chicken breast sautéed in white wine and butter, finished with bright lemon, briny capers, and a medley of julienned squash and zucchini.
    $29.00
  • Mediterranean Rack of Lamb

    Fire‑grilled rack of lamb served with cool, herb‑packed tzatziki, briny olives, and crumbled feta, paired with warm, pillowy naan for a rustic Mediterranean finish
    $52.00
  • Beef Stroganoff

    tender beef tenderloin and wild mushrooms simmered in a rich burgundy sauce, served over pappardelle noodles.
    $32.00

Seafood

  • Maple Plank Bourbon Salmon

    8 oz salmon filet grilled on a maple plank with a peach bourbon gastrique, served with sauteed vegetables
    $32.00
  • Jerk Ahi Tuna

    Sushi‑grade ahi tuna rubbed with bold jerk seasoning, served alongside a crisp jicama–green apple slaw for the perfect balance of heat and freshness.
    $38.00
  • Seafood Arrabiata

    Scallops, Spanish octopus, shrimp, and mussels tossed with fettuccine in a spicy, slow‑simmered tomato arrabiata sauce.
    $48.00
  • Miso Sea Bass

    delicate sea bass glazed with savory miso, paired with black garlic greenbeans in a vibrant Asian vegetable stir fry
    $58.00

Desserts

  • Crème Brûlée

    rich and silky vanilla bean custard, finished with a caramelized sugar crust and edible flower
    $9.00
  • The Scoop

    housemade vanilla bean, chocolate, or pistachio ice cream with homemade cotton candy and gold flake
    $9.00
  • Seasonal Crème Brûlée

    ask about this season's crème brûlée
    $9.00
  • Triple Layer Chocolate Mousse Cake

    a gluten-free brownie-like cake layer topped with a rich silky chocolate mousse and finished with a vanilla bean whipped cream and chocolate shavings
    $9.00

Drinks

Signature Cocktails

  • Colonel Geigers Old Fashioned

    our Signature Old Fashioned - You choose the Bourbon, and leave the rest to us. Pricing will vary based on bourbon preference.
    $3.00
  • Hamilton's Sin Garden

    take a GIN-based stroll with our mascot, through Lavender & Vanilla gardens. It's almost a sin to create a Martini this elegant.
    $15.00
  • Sandy Cheeks

    the cocktail should come with a WARNING label. Thick bodied, RUM-based, and dangerously tropical.
    $16.00
  • La'Picos & the Melon

    stimulate your palate with this riff on a Classic. smoky heat with watermelon and tequila creates an unbelievable flavour with balance.
    $15.00
  • Simplicity

    if you could take a slice of key lime Heaven, liquify it & add vodka...we're almost positive this is what you would get.
    $14.00
  • Amish Astronaut

    cucumber-infused vodka, along with some smash, & Blackberry Simple, all created in-house. A hint of Elderflower & Lime. A lil' Green Acres, a lil' Far Out
    $14.00
  • I don't Practice Sang-a-Ria

    part White Sangria, part Spritzer, yet 100% amazing, and now you have the sublime song in your mind. - Cheers
    $14.00
  • Hoosier Hee-Haw

    our mixologist version of a Kentucky Mule, done with that Indiana twist she proudly possesses, and yes, she grew up watching the show. IYKYK.
    $14.00

Sale

  • Urban Vines Chardonnay

    OUT OF STOCK
    $15.00
  • Freixenet Brut Champagne

    OUT OF STOCK
    $15.00
  • Louis Latour Pouilly Fusse

    $35.00

Butcher & Barrel Location and Hours

(812) 684-9888
416 East 4th Street, Huntingburg, IN 47542
Closed • Opens Wednesday at 4:30PM
View menu
Facebook logo
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement